Early stereo oddities and studio reverb are strong markers of a very different recording era.
Recordings from the sixties often sound strange to modern ears for reasons that have nothing to do with the songs. One is the reverb of the room the label used. Another is mono.
A single-channel mix forces everything into the same space, and that sounds remarkably distinct in a fragment. The instruments are balanced against each other rather than spread out, and the vocal is part of the same picture instead of standing in front of it. If a clip feels oddly flat or contained, mono is a reasonable first suspicion.
Reverb is the second marker. Studio chambers and plates were standard, and they produced a smooth, slightly dark tail that sounds unlike both the gated eighties and the modern algorithmic reverbs. The space is real and large, but soft at the edges.
The third marker is instrument tone. Guitars were twangier, organs were common, drum kits were tuned high with a noticeable snare ring, and the bass was often a round, simple line. Arrangements were frequently built around a rhythm section and one or two featured sounds rather than layers.
Dating these recordings is often easier than naming them because the field is smaller than it looks. If the clip sounds like the sixties, there are only a handful of production styles it can belong to, and each style narrows the artist list quickly.
You can train the pattern on free practice by asking whether the recording sounds wide or contained. Most players find that the contained recordings cluster in one decade, and that the cluster behaves like a shortcut for the rest of their listening life.
A quick test is to listen for stereo movement. A lot of sixties recordings place instruments hard left and right with very little in the middle, and that arrangement feels odd in a clip. If the picture is strangely split, the recording is probably early stereo, and early stereo is one of the most reliable dates in the catalogue.